| Date of Review |
November 2005 |
| Manufacturer |
Accurate Miniatures |
| Subject |
SB2C-1C Helldiver |
| Scale |
1/48 |
| Kit Number |
480405 |
| Primary Media |
Styrene |
| Detail Media |
Styrene/Photo-Etch |
| Clear Media |
Styrene |
| Pros |
Excellent exterior and interior detailing, photo-etched details |
| Cons |
Decals (see text); window templates not correct |
| Skill Level |
Basic |
| MSRP (USD) |
$39.98 |
Background
The SB2C Helldiver was one of the most effective dive bombers
developed in World War 2 and served well into the 1950s. Ironically,
the Helldiver spent more time as a prototype than a combat aircraft
during WW2. For those who remember the movie 'Dive Bomber' that
was released before WW2, there was a silhouette of an aircraft
at the end of the movie - the XSB2C-1. The Helldiver was entering
flight test before the war and might have retired the Douglas SBD
early if all had gone well.
But all did not go well. The prototypes kept experiencing structural
problems that resulted in in-flight break-ups during dives - not
a good trait for a dive bomber. The problems persisted to the point
where the Curtiss-Wright company was targeted by the Truman Commission
which recognized that since the issuance of the production contract
in 1939 through the present (1943), Curtiss has yet to develop
a single Helldiver that the US Navy considered to be an effective
combat aircraft.
While many of the major bugs had been ironed out, the SB2C-1C
was released into service in late 1943 to fill the urgent need
for combat aircraft. Recognizing that many problems still existed,
the pilots were given restrictions on portions of the flight envelope
to keep crews from experiencing the wrath of the Beast.
VB-17 was the first US Navy squadron to take the Helldiver into
combat on 11 November 1943, launching from the USS Bunker Hill
against the Japanese-held island of Rabaul. The VB-17 was the second
strike into the Japanese anchorage and the Zeros were waiting.
Despite heavy opposition from fighters and flak, the Beasts were
able to fight their way into the target area, dive upon the ships
below, strike several effective blows, and fight their way back
out, all without a single casualty. Several Helldivers were seriously
shot up and a few had to ditch near the carrier group's destroyer
screen, but everyone made it home from their combat debut.
Note: VB-17 did not fly the SB2C-1C at Rabaul or anytime
on their first Helldiver cruise. Thanks to Brian O'Neill's efforts
for showing that the VB-17 Helldivers at Rabaul were SB2C-1 Mod
III versions with twin 50 calibers in each wing instead of the
later single 20mm in each wing. One historical reference for
this is on the bottom of page 18 of Bert Kinzey's SB2C
Helldiver in Detail & Scale. In fact, in Peter Smith's Curtiss
SB2C Helldiver, VB-17 never flew the SB2C-1C in combat. When they
completed their tour in the SB2C-1 Mod III, they were re-equipped
with the SB2C-3 and SB2C-4 before returning to combat.
The Kit
All of the speculation is over. Accurate Miniatures has released
their duo of Helldiver kits based upon the Pro-Modeler molds (Revell-Monogram).
This release is the SB2C-1C, the first version to see combat. In
general, the details between this version and the late-war SB2C-4
are few but visible. All are addressed here.
The kit is molded in light gray styrene and features some beautifully
scribed detailing on the exterior surfaces and nice interior detailing
as well. The kit is presented on four parts trees, plus a single
tree of clear parts and a single fret of photo-etch.
The first four trees are common to both kits. The fifth tree is
the new three-bladed propeller and two-piece spinner common to
the SB2C-1, A-25A, and Helldiver Mk.I.
The photo-etch parts are similar to the fret from the SB2C-4 kit
except this set lacks the perforated dive brakes of the late-model
Beast. This new photo-etch set, made by Eduard, is the same as
the set in the SB2C-4 kit except the perforations in the dive flaps
were deleted. The sawtooth trailing edge of the upper dive flaps
should have also been deleted and will need to be trimmed away.
The photo-etch provides seatbelt buckles and gun sight details
as well as an ignition harness in addition to the dive brakes.
Another notable difference in the SB2C-1C is the window behind
the pilot's cockpit. On page four of the instructions is a template
to help you to modify the fuselage halves with the 'correct' shaped
windows. While the window behind the pilot on the left side was
an inverted 'L', the window on the right side was rectangular.
Those of you who've built the Pro-Modeler SB2C-4 kit already know
how well this kit goes together. Those who haven't are in for a
treat. The kit features beautifully detailed front and rear cockpits
as well as a nice weapons bay on the flipside of the floor. A pilot's
figure is also included.
The engine looks a little low-tech on the parts tree, but when
treated to a good paint job, the photo-etched ignition harness
and installed inside that tight cowling, you would be hard-pressed
to tell it wasn't an aftermarket resin engine.
The wings are unfortunately not set up for an optional fold, but
they are nicely detailed down to the stub rocket launchers, wheel
wells, dive brakes and outboard slats.
The other minor nit of the kit, not of Accurate Miniatures' doing,
is the retractable rear fairing. The Beast would lower the rear
deck aft of the rear cockpit to allow better clearance for the
rear guns' barrels. This retractable deck includes the leading
edge base of the vertical stabilizer as pictured in the Accurate
Miniatures profile on the instructions. A little surgery with an
X-Acto knife while you're modifying the fuselage for the additional
window will fix this.
Profiles and markings are included for two examples:
- SB2C-1C, White 4, VB-17, USS Bunker Hill
- SB2C-1C, White 18, VB-2, USS Hornet
Actually, as you'll see in the decal image, Accurate Miniatures
has provided a variety of numbers to replicate 11 different aircraft
- check your references. According to the instructions, if you
want maintenance stencils, you'll need to find Aeromaster sheet
148-120.
Update Note:
A follow-up note on the decals. It turns out according to Bert
Kinzey's book SB2C Helldiver in Detail & Scale, that VB-17
didn't take the SB2C-1C to Rabaul. They were still operating the
SB2C-1 Mod III Helldiver which differed visibly by its wing armament.
The SB2C-1C (and later) Helldiver was armed with a single 20mm
cannon in the wing root, as depicted in the Pro-Modeler/Accurate
Miniatures kit. The SB2C-1 Mod III was armed with twin 50 caliber
machine guns in each wing root. If you want to do a VB-17 Rabaul
raider, you'll need to add an additional gun port in each wing
- a minor backdate. These decals are accurate for VB-17 at Rabaul.
If you do want to build the kit straight out of the box, you won't
be doing a Rabaul aircraft, but since the Accurate Miniatures decals
are essentially generic markings, you can check your references
and apply the markings accordingly.
Summary
This kit is a beauty straight out of the box and is a straightforward build.
With all of the detail in this kit, even the AMS modeler should
be satisfied without additional aftermarket details. While the
folks at Accurate Miniatures may have gotten their history off
slightly, we still have the first-ever option to backdate the ProModeler
Helldiver with minimal effort.
My sincere thanks to Accurate Miniatures for the review sample.
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
FAQS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
SPACE
NAVAL
HISTORY
CALENDAR
COLORS
TIPS
COMING SOON
ABOUT
|