| Date of Review |
March 2009 |
| Manufacturer |
Hasegawa |
| Subject |
B-24J Liberator |
| Scale |
1/72 |
| Kit Number |
00947 |
| Primary Media |
Styrene |
| Detail Media |
Styrene |
| Clear Media |
Styrene |
| Pros |
Easy build, nice details |
| Cons |
|
| Skill Level |
Basic |
| MSRP (USD) |
$82.95 |
Background
The B-24 Liberator was a mixed blessing to the war effort.
It was produced in much larger numbers than the B-17 even though
production didn't begin until after the start of the war. Thanks
to Henry Ford, the first real aircraft mass production line
was established in Willow Run, MI and B-24s were reaching all
theaters of operations.
Despite their greater availability, bomber crews preferred
the B-17. Even though the B-24 was faster, more modern, and
had greater capabilities, it was also less stable and much
more work for the pilots. Cartoons from the period indicated
that B-24 pilots could be spotted at the pub because of their
one massive left arm required to keep the aircraft in the air.
Copilots were recognized by their massive right arms.
The Liberator was not only flown by the USAAF, the RAF operated
a number of the aircraft, as did the US Navy. In fact, the
Navy built the ultimate B-24 by stretching the fuselage, replacing
the twin vertical stabilizers with one huge fin, and creating
an effective maritime patrol aircraft - the PB4Y-2 Privateer.
One pilot of the B-24 moved through the ranks of command during
his time in the Mighty Eighth Air Force. Actor-turned-pilot
Jimmy Stewart had to work hard to be recognized for his skill
and leadership made difficult by his star status in Hollywood.
Nevertheless, Stewart worked hard to stay out of way of the
press so that those that served under him would receive their
well-deserved recognition. He enlisted as a Private at the
start of the war and by the end of the war he had risen to
full Colonel, not as a token public relations figurehead, but
as a true combat leader of a B-24 squadron and later as the
operations officer of a B-24 bomb group. According to General
Hap Arnold, if the war in Europe had lasted another month,
Jimmy Sterwart would have been commanding his own B-24 bomb
group.
The Kit
When Hasegawa announced this special edition version of their
still relatively new 1/72 B-24J kit, I decided it was time
to take a first look at this new tooling. For the longest time,
your only choice for a B-24 in 1/72 scale were the Academy/Minicraft
line of Liberators. While these were reportedly not bad kits,
they were good basic models of the airframe. So what is different
about the Hasegawa tooling? What would happen if the engineers
at Trumpeter designed a Hasegawa kit? You'd get a super detailed
model straight out of the box! That's just what we have here.
The kit is molded in light gray styrene and presented on nine
parts trees, plus one tree of clear parts. The layout of the
kit is fairly conventional, but they've done some innovation
to make the project easier. One of the complaints with the
Academy/Minicraft Liberators was the windscreen. Hasegawa has
taken a different approach to the entire nose as we'll see
shortly. As you'd expect with a contemporary tooling from Hasegawa,
the surface detailing is finely scribed and no sign of any
'mad riveter'.
The first thing you'll notice about the project is the interior
- Hasegawa has developed a nearly full-length interior for
this model. The interior for the main fuselage runs from the
nose break right at the rear of the cockpit, encloses a detailed
bomb bay, sets up the waist gunner compartment, and ends aft
of that area. The gunner's area has the gun pintles and .50
caliber machine guns, but you won't see much in there with
the waist windows closed. Should you open the windows, you
can add some additional details there for the ammo boxes, O2
bottles/regulators, and the hydraulic jack that hangs from
the ceiling to extend and retract the ventral turret.
The wings have a main spar that carries through the fuselage
and provides a solid join at the wing/fuselage joint. The joint
looks like it will make adding the wings after you've painted
or metalized the model much easier, which in turn makes painting
far easier.
As I mention, the bomb bay is nicely detailed and armed. The
bomb bay dooes can be posed open or closed.
Hasegawa went the extra mile with the engines - they have
these with the complete twin banks of cylinders attached to
a rear firewall rather than a simple plug that goes inside
the cowling. When you look into the cowlings, you'll see the
depth.
Which brings me to the Achilles Heel of every US WW2 bomber
model - the windows. The B-17 and B-24 in particular were getting
different window configurations, especially in the nose. If
you looked at a B-17G for example, there are something like
five different window configurations depending on early or
late B-17G and which factory produced the aircraft. The B-24
was also the recipient of window changes.
In this kit, Hasegawa tackled the window fit problem found
in other B-24 models by molding the entire nose in clear. The
side windows in the cockpit are molded separately so you can
select the correct windows for your project - bulged or non-bulged,
both of which are provided. The windscreen and overhead windows
are all one part that also extends forward to include the top
of the nose and the navigator's astrodome. This allows Hasegawa
to swap these clear sections to render different variants easier,
but still make the model easier to assemble.
Where
this innovation goes awry is up front. The box art depicts
the window configurations correctly with larger, almost square
side windows in the nose behind the turret and beneath the
astrodome. This is the correct configuration for the real 'Dragon
and its Tail' B-24J, but the kit and instructions depict this
same window as a narrow rectangle as found on the 'Dragon and
its Tail' warbird that is flying the airshow circuit. You can
see in the close-up image the small rectangular window at the
top behind where the turret installs.
Below that window is
a larger window that goes on either side of the bombardier's
nose glazing. That window should be further forward where the
ejector pin part is, and for some odd reason, there is a panel
line and rivet line molded right across that window as well
as where the window should be. The window designer and the
panel line designer didn't coordinate here.
It is nearly impossible to get all of the windows right in
every B-17 and B-24 kit without going to the expense of tooling
all of those little differences and passing those expenses
on to us.
Markings
The kit includes decals for one B-24J
Liberator:
- B-24J, 973, 64 BS/43 BG(H), 'Dragon and its Tail'
The decal sheet provides the instrument panel in decal form
and these markings are really nicely done.
Conclusions
This is one of the more colorful 'nose' art renderings applied
to any US combat aircraft and Hasegawa has used this with an
equally impressive new B-24J kit. The details and options in
this model clearly make the Hasegawa series of Liberators the
best B-24 models in any scale.
Definitely recommended!
This kit was available at under $55 USD from HobbyLink Japan
here. The
'Dragon' was under limited edition release, but the base
kit is still available at the same price.
My sincere thanks to HobbyLink
Japan for this review sample!
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
NAVAL
SPACE
HISTORY
MUSEUM
CALENDAR
COLOR REFS
WRITERS GUIDE
TIPS
FUTURE KITS
ABOUT
READERS GALLERY
LOGOS
SOLAR MONITOR
FAQS
SPECIAL
STAFF
CONTACT
|