| Date of Review |
April 2007 |
| Manufacturer |
Skif |
| Subject |
T-55A |
| Scale |
1/35 |
| Kit Number |
0221 |
| Primary Media |
277 parts (237 in medium green styrene,
34 etched brass, 6 in steel colored vinyl) |
| Pros |
Dimensionally relatively accurate; provides
the basics for a complete interior |
| Cons |
Details very soft, wheels totally wrong,
undersized hatches |
| Skill Level |
Basic |
| MSRP (USD) |
$25-36 |
The T-55 has fared a bit better in model form than the more widely
operated T-54 series medium tanks, but their history in kit form
has not been a great one.
The first 1/35 (well, nominally anyway) kit to see market was
a motorized one from Tamiya that came out in the mid 1960s. As
the ONLY kit of this vehicle out for years, it did enjoy a great
deal of popularity among kit collectors up until 1989, even though
it was a PA kit – as in plain awful.
In 1988 a company called Twentieth Century Industries (TCI) displayed
artwork for a new 1/35 scale kit of the T-55 in Nurnberg, but they
never made it to market. Apparently Lindberg bought their molds,
as they released all of the announced TCI kits the next year. The
T-55 was eagerly awaited, and when released did at first glance
look like a T-55. Alas, its details were all a bit off (angles,
sizes, wheels, fuel tanks, etc.), the turret was symmetrical, and
as such it soon became known as a "dog."
About two years later ESCI announced three T-55 related kits and
once again Soviet armor fans got excited. But when the kits came
out they were a bit better than the Lindberg one but still had
major errors, albeit new ones. This kit had wrong wheels and even
a wrong suspension (the last road wheel station was "leading" link,
not "trailing" link as shown in the kit) and many, many
more detail errors. Result: 0 for 3.
Finally, SKIF announced that they would do a T-55A kit. This was
met with more than a bit of trepidation given SKIF's notorious
erratic kits (either reasonably good or awful) and modelers waited
to see which was which. Unfortunately, shortly after this kit was
released, Tamiya announced a new kit of the T-55 which would build
up as a T-55, T-55A, T-55 Model 1970 or T-55A Model 1970.
I have to feel a bit sorry for SKIF. At any other point in time
this kit would probably have been reasonably well received, but
alas it came to market just before the Tamiya one and as a result
took an initial pasting by kit reviewers and modelers. But once
the Tamiya kit was announced, this kit was ripped to shreds and
decried as awful. Looking at the kits side by side at the time,
I had to concur that it was not even close.
Fast forward to 2007. I picked up one of these kits at AMPS 2007
from Baseline Hobbies to see if in the cold light of day it was
still that bad. The answer, surprisingly, is no.
What SKIF tried to do was make a kit of a T-55A Model 1970 (e.g.
with DshKM AAMG mount for the loader) with some basic upgrades
such as the RMSh (T-72 style) tracks and a laser rangefinder. They
also gave the kit a relatively complete interior.
The good news is that dimensionally the kit is accurate within
limits with the only major flaws being the gun barrel is about
2.5 mm too long, and the wheels appear to be a bit narrow. The
turret's shape drops right on top of a good set of T-55 plans that
I have in 1/35 scale, so it got the asymmetric shape right. Hull
angles and dimensions also match well with the plans. Shapes are
also very good.
The rest, alas, is not so hot. The wheels – other than the
correct diameter – have little in common with standard production "starfish" wheels
for the T-55 and are best chucked. The tracks are thin and lack
definition but are tangibly RMSh tracks; they are marred by ejection
pin marks on their faces, which are virtually impossible to remove
from vinyl. The drivers and idlers are thick but shapes are again
close.
The rear of the engine deck is not bad with etched brass screening,
but the access hatches are not right in shape and are raised panel
lines which are not right at all. The fender fuel tanks are
primitive and there is no fuel system for them (at least they got
all three the correct size, unlike ESCI.) The same goes for the
fender stowage bins.
The turret shape is right, but that is about the limit of things.
The hatches are "drop-in" parts which are far too thick
and as a result they are underscale and not close to the actual
vehicle's hatches. The gun is designed to work and therefore SKIF
tried to simply use the "pig's snout" mantelet without
the cover; that in and of itself is not wrong, but the result is
too big and too rectangular and is therefore not very good. The
gun's diameter is about right, but the bore evacuator is too short
and too small in diameter.
Inside the hull the details are in the right places, but again
are very soft and need a great deal of work to come up to acceptable
levels. SKIF tried to be creative by molding both sides of the
belly pan with details; the torsion bar bulges are on the belly,
and the floor and interior location ridges are on the other side;
result is that the part is too thin and the rear is very oversimplified,
but at least it was not 1/4" thick like the Alan SU-76 kit.
The engine, transmission, "guitar" transfer case, and
other engine compartment bits are very simplified, and to make
matters worse, SKIF left out half of the major parts – the
radiator, oil cooler and air cleaner are all missing! The driver's
compartment is very spartan (the parts are at least correct for
what is provided) as is the turret.
Brass parts are used here and there, with the main components
for the engine deck grilles (with no louvers under them as on the
actual vehicle) and fan blades being the majority of the parts.
The kit comes with a small decal sheet for a Soviet Guards vehicle
and for an East German NVA vehicle.
The reason I even bring this kit up is that with some parts from
the soon to be redundant Tamiya "T-62A" kit this model
may be made into a very presentable T-55A. I say that as the new
Trumpeter T-62 Model 1966 and T-62 Model 1970 kit test shots show
they have fixed most of the errors in that 30 year old kit, and
as they can usually be had for $5-10 at model shows and flea markets
now they are a useful supply of spare parts.
By taking most of the details from that kit such as the fuel tanks,
applicable stowage bins, DShKM, hatches, searchlights, and other
minor details and using a set of resin wheels from companies such
as Chesapeake Model Design or Miniarm this kit can be done right,
or it could be converted into a T-54 variant with a bit of work
and one of the Miniarm conversion kits plus "spider" cast
wheels and the early metallic tracks (like the ones which came
in the "T-62A" kit but from another company such as
Fruil.)
I will give it a whirl at some point in the future and report
back on my results.
Return to the Armor/AFV Menu
|