| Date of Review |
January 2008 |
| Manufacturer |
Trumpeter |
| Subject |
P-51B Mustang II |
| Scale |
1/32 |
| Kit Number |
2274 |
| Primary Media |
Styrene |
| Detail Media |
Styrene, Photo-Etch |
| Clear Media |
Styrene |
| Pros |
Superdetailed and superbly engineered |
| Cons |
Rivets on the wings, a few detail glitches,
but nothing difficult |
| Skill Level |
Intermediate |
| MSRP (USD) |
$94.95 |
Background
As most Mustang-lovers know, this aircraft was designed and
paid for by the British government. Delegates from Great Britain
came to the US to acquire combat aircraft (among other things)
to stave off the oncoming Nazi threat. While the US was still
neutral, its production lines were made available. Having signed
a production deal with Curtiss for the P-40, the delegates
came to North American Aviation to enlist them to co-produce
the P-40. Instead, North American designers convinced the delegates
that they'd have a superior aircraft ready to fly in less than
a year, and so Mustang I was born. It was powered by the Allison
V-1710 engine. While these were great at low level, they could
not carry the fight up to medium altitudes due to the limitations
of the Allison's mechanical supercharger.
The RAF took one of their Mustang Is and hung a Merlin 61
on the nose. They were astonished at the vast improvement in
performance of the aircraft in low and medium altitudes, and
even able to reach 40,000 feet. North American transitioned
production to incorporate the license-built Packard Merlin
V-1650 engine, and the P-51B/C were born.
The Kit
The only choice a modeler had for a 1/32 P-51B/C
Mustang was Revell's classic kit. In fact, early Mustangs were
simply not available in this scale. Thankfully, the popularity
of 1/32 scale had drawn the attention of numerous hobby companies
and we're getting more up-to-date kits to choose from. In the
case of the first Packard-Merlin-powered Mustangs, the Revell
kit has held up over the decades and is still a reasonable
model for beginning modeler.
Trumpeter has released their much anticipated 1/32 kit and
it follows nicely in the same path as their magnificent 1/32
P-47 Thunderbolts. The kit is molded in standard Trumpeter
light gray styrene and presented on 11 parts trees. In addition
to one tree of clear parts for the canopy options and windscreen,
Trumpeter also ran clear styrene through the fuselage molds
and rendered a duplicate tree in clear should you want to show
off the interior of your model. The kit is rounded out with
a pair of photo-etched frets with finer details, plus some
nice decals.
The detailing on the kit's surfaces is finely scribed and
include lots of rivet details. While this will be more visible
on bare metal schemes, they will significantly subdued with
standard camouflage colors. Like most of the 'other' Mustang
releases, this kit has rivet details on the wings which is
incorrect as North American delivered a sealed and smooth laminar
flow wing to achieve the performance that made this aircraft
famous. But you know what? I've seen some of the DML 1/32 P-51D
kits with the larger rivets molded in the wing surfaces and
the completed models still look nice.
No model company has
ever made the perfect model and the P-51 is one that few have
come close to getting right. Even so, I've enjoyed building
these models because they still look like Mustangs and I enjoy
the paint schemes as much as the details.
This P-51B kit
captures the look of the Packard Merlin though the AMS modeler
will have an opportunity to add their own details like ignition
wiring and additional plumbing. Is the engine the right scale
size? I've seen some discussion on this and the answer is simple
- who cares? Unless you're going to pull the engine out of
the aircraft, this engine is sized to fit under that hood.
So what will you see if you build the model with the clear
fuselage halves? Besides a nicely detailed engine, you have
a good view into the cockpit, the ventral coolant radiators,
the main fuselage fuel cell and radio tray, the oxygen storage
cylinders, and the tail wheel well. If Trumpeter had put the
wings and tail through the clear molds as well, you'd have
a nice companion to Monogram's famous 1/32 Phantom Mustang
(P-51D).
One thing very nice about this kit, Trumpeter has not reverted
back to those awful photo-etch flight control hinges. The kit
provides positionable flight control surfaces. In fact, the
kit has a number of nice features:
- A better attempt at the main wheel wells than some
- Four .50 caliber machine guns and ammo trays (you'll need
to create shell ejector chutes under the wings)
- Overwing gun access panels
- Positionable ailerons, rudder and elevators
- Positionable flaps
- Detailed Packard Merlin right down to the ventral ductwork
- Removable dorsal engine access panel
- Photo-etched seatbelts/shoulder harness
- Choice of styrene or PE/acetate instrument panel
- Choice of open or closed standard hood
- Optional Malcolm hood
- Rubber tires
As for external stores:
- 2 x metal drop tanks
- 2 x paper drop tanks
- 2 x bazooka rocket launchers
- 2 x bombs
The sprues have additional rockets included that are not used
in this version.
Markings
For markings, the kit has one of my all-time favorite P-51B
schemes - 'Ding Hao' that I remember on Monogram's early 1/48
P-51B Mustang kit decades ago. There are two schemes in this
kit:
- P-51B-5-NA, 43-6315, 365 FS/345 FG/9 AF, AJ-A, 'Ding Hao'
(Very Good in Chinese), as flown by Major James Howard, 365
FS CO who was also awarded the Medal of Honor
- P-51B-15-NA, 43-24857, 319 FS/325 FG, 90, 'Sweet Clara
II'
Conclusion
I like this kit. I've seen some of the criticisms of the model
posted online, but many of these issues can be dealt with.
The model is far and away a better starting point for my next
AMS project than the Revell kit I had acquired, and I may even
steal a few parts out of that model to complete the project
as well. We shall see!
So now you have two choices for a styrene-based P-51B/C in
1/32 scale. As complex as this model will be to build, I would
still recommend the Revell kit to younger modelers, but here
is some nice raw material to achieve that P-51B/C you've wanted.
Highly recommended!
My sincere thanks to Stevens
International for this review sample!
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
NAVAL
SPACE
HISTORY
MUSEUM
CALENDAR
COLOR REFS
WRITERS GUIDE
TIPS
FUTURE KITS
ABOUT
READERS GALLERY
LOGOS
SOLAR MONITOR
FAQS
SPECIAL
STAFF
CONTACT
|