| Date of Review |
March 2007 |
| Manufacturer |
Trumpeter |
| Subject |
Hawker Hurricane Mk.I |
| Scale |
1/24 |
| Kit Number |
2414 |
| Primary Media |
Styrene |
| Detail Media |
Styrene & Photo-Etch |
| Clear Media |
Styrene |
| Pros |
Nice detailing inside and out |
| Cons |
|
| Skill Level |
Intermediate |
| MSRP (USD) |
$149.95 |
Background
The Hawker Hurricane was one of those pivotal aircraft in the
right place at the right time. The aircraft was designed in the
mid 1930s at that time in aviation history when airpower was trading
in its biplanes for monoplane designs.
The first Hurricanes weren't too much of a stretch from their
two-winged cousins as their wings were still fabric covered and
built using the same technologies. Metal covered wings would soon
follow.
By the time the war in Europe broke out in late 1939, the Hurricane
was reaching obsolescence and the Supermarine Spitfire was entering
service. With war thrust upon them, the RAF made use of every available
air asset, and this included the Hurricane.
In the Battle of Britain, one-on-one, the Hurricane's performance
wasn't up to par with the Bf 109. What made the difference in this
crucial air war was pure numbers. The Hurricane was available in
the thousands and significantly outnumbered the available Spitfires.
It also packed a significant punch with its eight Browning .303
machine guns. While the RAF paid a heavy price in attrition, the
brave pilots withstood the best that Hermann Goering could throw
at them. The Hurricane soldiered on through the remainder of the
war with improvements in power and armament, and would equip the
air arms of allied forces around the globe.
The Kit
When I heard that Trumpeter was going to release the Hawker Hurricane
in 1/24, I wasn't sure what to expect. The long-time king of this
scale subject has been the Airfix 1/24 Hurricane Mk.I, and while
the design of the kit is a bit dated, it was remarkably detailed
without being over-engineered. Over-engineered translates into
several hundred of tiny parts that would make assembling this model
a chore.
When build-ups of the Trumpeter test shots were posted on the
web, it was clear that the model had the right shape and look,
but would it be better than the Airfix kit? Let's take a look.
According to the specifications, this kit is molded in light gray
styrene and presented on nine parts trees, two trees molded in
clear, one fret of photo-etched parts, and a set of rubber tires
for the main gear and tailwheel. To be honest, I hadn't looked
at the specs when I opened the box, so I didn't know what to expect.
Inside the box was a VERY nicely detailed model that had several
distinct differences from earlier 1/24 scale releases:
- No photo-etched flight control hinges (YES!)
- Straighforward parts layout
- Very few 'tiny' parts
- Well-executed fabric surfaces
In short, this model looks similar to the Airfix kit but with
much sharper details. Much to my surprise, the parts count for
the Airfix kit is 261, the Trumpeter comes in at 260.
Like the Airfix kit, the gun bays are molded open on top of the
wings and are fully populated with guns, ammo chutes, etc. The
Merlin engine and support systems are rendered in both kits, but
the Trumpeter kit seems to have nicer detailing. While the Trumpeter
kit doesn't have a removable 'hood' to reveal the engine (it can
be surgically removed), it does offer clear side cowling panels
should you care to display the engine from one or both sides. For
that matter, you could leave one or both of the clear panels off,
your call.
The cockpit is nicely appointed down to the acetate instrument
faces that show through the clear instrument panel (that you paint
up short of the instrument glass faces). The Sutton harness is
provided in photo-etch.
Where the Trumpeter kit starts to get a bit over-engineered is
with the provided leading edge and main wing fuel tanks. These
are a nice touch, but aren't seen again after the wing tops are
cemented into place. If this is the worst of the over-engineering
(and it is), then the designers exercised a great deal of restraint.
The ailerons, flaps, elevators, and rudder are all separately
molded and can positioned to taste. As I mentioned earlier, there
are no hinges, so the control surfaces will stay put after assembly.
If you do want something to fiddle with on the aircraft, the propeller
can be left movable and the sliding canopy is also designed to
be movable.
Decals
Markings are included for two aircraft:
- Hurricane Mk.I, V6864, 257 Sqn, DT-A, as flown by Sqn Ldr Robert
Stanford Tuck
- Hurricane Mk.I, P2798, 87 Sqn, LK-A, as flown by Sqn Ldr Ian
Gleed
As with many of Trumpeter's instruction sets, the color call-outs
are suspect and should be cross-checked with other references.
Conclusion
So, at an MSRP of $150, is the Trumpeter kit better than the Airfix
kit? From what I can see the soon-to-be-reissued Airfix Hurricane
will have an MSRP of $85. While both kits have similar features
and details, the Trumpeter kit features crisper details and will
likely not have some of the fit challenges that the Airfix kit
has exhibited. What's more this kit does have some photo-etched
details including a nice Sutton harness. With the street prices
on both kits being lower, will the Trumpeter kit be worth the extra
cost. Absolutely.
This kit is definitely recommended!
My sincere thanks to Stevens
International for this review sample!
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
FAQS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
SPACE
NAVAL
HISTORY
CALENDAR
COLORS
TIPS
COMING SOON
ABOUT
|