| Date of Review |
February 2006 |
| Manufacturer |
Trumpeter |
| Subject |
CH-47A Chinook |
| Scale |
1/35 |
| Kit Number |
5104 |
| Primary Media |
Styrene |
| Detail Media |
Styrene, Photo-Etch, White Metal |
| Clear Media |
Styrene |
| Pros |
Excellent detailing inside and out. Very
nice use of photo-etch for engine intake filters and grilles |
| Cons |
Decals |
| Skill Level |
Intermediate |
| MSRP (USD) |
$149.95 |
Background
In June 1959, the Army issued a specification for a new Battlefield
Mobility Helicopter which could carry 40 fully equipped troops
or two tons of cargo internally or up to eight tons of cargo via
external sling. In addition, the aircraft would have to be able
to transport any component of the Pershing missile system.
While
a number of designs were submitted, the Model 114 from Boeing/Vertol
was selected. This aircraft bore more than a slight resemblance
to the Model 107 that was being operated by the US Navy as the
CH-46, but the Model 114/CH-47A was a significantly more powerful
aircraft. Where the CH-46S was initially powered by a pair of 1,400
shp engines, the CH-47A started off with a pair of 2,650 shp engines.
The Model 114 made its first flight in September 1961 and entered
service soon afterwards. Fairing pods on each side of the aircraft
housed the non-retractable quadricycle landing gear and large portions
of these pods were sealed to provide buoyancy to the aircraft while
it operated from water.
I remember a marketing trip
that Boeing/Vertol took to South America many years ago and the
crew landed their Chinook in Lake Titicaca. What's so impressive
about that? Any helicopter operating from water must be able to
lift itself back out of the water as well as the weight of any
water that naturally enters the aircraft. This is challenging enough
at sea level, but Lake Titicaca is located high in the Andes mountains
at over 12,500 feet, well above the safe hover altitude for most
helicopters. The Chinook took the challenge in stride, attesting
to the brute power of the aircraft.
The Chinook didn't have long to wait before its baptism of fire,
the CH-47A went to war in Vietnam, proving its worth many times
over.
The Kit
Here is another much-anticipated release from Trumpeter - the
CH-47A Chinook in 1/35 scale. As you'd imagine, the kit is rather
large given that it is released in the popular scale of armor modelers.
Molded in light gray styrene, the kit is presented on eight parts
trees, plus two additional trees of clear parts. In addition, the
two forward and two rear fuselage halves are packaged separately
in a very impressive manner to ensure their survival through shipping.
A small box inside the main kit box contains the clear nose dome
part, rubber tires, and white metal landing gear struts. One package
of photo-etched parts is stored with the fuselage halves. Excellent
packaging job Trumpeter!
Trumpeter has also done a nice job with the parts breakdown so
as to be able to render the CH-47D with a minimum of new parts
required.
As I pulled each part tree out of the box for imaging, I noticed
that tree J, containing the rotor blades, was slightly warped.
I don't know if this is intentional or a fortunate coincidence
as the 'warpage' renders near-perfect droop to the blades! I'm
going to assume this is intentional and once again render congratulations!
Assembly begins with the cockpit and this is a nicely detailed
affair. While I wouldn't be surprised to see a new detail set from
Cobra Company for this beauty, you'll have a nice model from what
is in the box! The instrument panel is molded in clear and an acetate
sheet is provided with instrument faces to be mounted behind the
panel. You have but to mask the instrument faces on the panel and
paint the panel accordingly. I'm not sure how well the acetate
instrument faces will be visible through the thickness of the panel,
so I'd consider using a Waldron punch to remove the instrument
faces from the acetate sheet and mount them to the front of the
panel.
The center console is nicely detailed and will look great with
some dry-brushing to make that detail stand out. The crew seats
are also nicely done and these are complimented with photo-etched
seatbelts and harnesses.
As with the CH-46, the Chinook has a pair of bulkheads that separate
the cockpit from the cargo compartment. In between these bulkheads
are racks for aircraft avionics and supplies. This is rendered
nicely in the kit and would be enhanced with a little cabling if
such detailing would be visible from outside the model.
The cargo compartment has detailing molded on the insides for
the fuselage halves, and separate cargo floor and ceiling are provided
to 'box in' the compartment.
For a change, the engines in this kit are not over-engineered
with lots of details. What Trumpeter has done is provided just
what is needed to render the powerplants with the engine nacelle
covers closed. Don't worry, you'll still see engine as all of the
vents and grilles are rendered in photo-etch.
The crew entry door can be positioned open or closed. The rear
cargo ramp can also be positioned open or closed
There is a nice array of antenna posts mounted on the port side
of the aircraft, which will require significant care in handling
considering how early these are installed. I will probably wait
until the very end to add these posts. What is interesting is that
Trumpeter didn't provide any instructions for routing the HF antenna
wire through these posts, so you'll have to hit the internet or
your references to see how to properly route your antenna.
Markings are provided for two examples:
- CH-47A, 410108, US Army Systems Command, 1966
- CH-47A, 57887, 228 ASHB, 1st Cav Div, Lai Khe, Vietnam, 1970
Update
I received the following email which quite nicely explains a few
features of the full-scale Chinook from someone who used to keep
them ready to fly:
Mr. Benolkin;
Very nicely done review on the CH-47A in today's issue of Cybermodeler.
There are some very fairly informative discussions on the FSM helicopter
forum that has been going on between myself and several others
who have spent long hours working on and flying in these aircraft.
The kit IS very nicely designed and to most few, if any of the
shortcomings will be noticed.
The warpage you speak of is found on ALL helicopter rotor blades
regardless of type because they serve as the means of propulsion
as well as lift. Just think of the twist in a propeller blade and
you will understand.
If built according to the instructions, a modeler may be a bit
confused when it comes to the ramp and hatch at the rear. On CH-46s
the hatch retracted in and up into the aft cabin area, on CH-47s
a different approach was used. The hatch actually retracts into
the ramp when the ramp is lowered. In the instructions it seems
to imply that the hatch should be glued to the fuselage while the
ramp is positioned in the lowered position. If the ramp is to be
depicted in the lowered position, then the hatch should be shown
retracted into the ramp. (I know it sounds confusing and it easier
to understand if you could see the process in action)
The standoffs for the HF antenna are a tad too long, cutting
them so they are about as half as long would be more accurate.
The big disappointment for me was the lack of detail on the interior
of the aft pylon. On CH-46 models a person could get away with
no detail because the hatch when retracted inwards blocks the
aft transmission, generators, flight boost and utility pumps
and associated wiring and plumbing from view, when the ramp is
lowered on a CH-47 all of those components are visible. There
are other problems with this kit, but happily the areas they
got right were the rotor systems to include the rainshield, the
pitch change links (even if they do give the wrong color to paint
them) both swashplates (rotating and stationary) and the drive
links. Hell, they even have the lugs for the swiveling and pivoting
actuators on the stationary swashplate! It is almost as if they
had multiple people researching different parts of the aircraft.
Yes it is a good kit, and yes I will get at least one more and
I plan on getting two of the CH-47Ds when they are released.
Again, an very good appraisal of a good kit, I just wanted to
give you a perspective from some old fart who spent a bunch of
time working on and crewing these magnificent aircraft.
Jonathan Primm
Youngsville, LA
Thank you Jonathan!
Conclusion
This is an impressive kit straight out of the box and will lend
itself to some interesting displays and dioramas at the next round
of IPMS contests.
Definitely recommended!
My sincere thanks to Stevens
International for this review sample!
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
FAQS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
SPACE
NAVAL
HISTORY
CALENDAR
COLORS
TIPS
COMING SOON
ABOUT
|