| Date of Review |
November 2004 |
| Manufacturer |
21st Century Toys |
| Subject |
M4 Sherman |
| Scale |
1/32 |
| Kit Number |
N/A |
| Primary Media |
15 parts (3 major subassemblies, 6 separate "detail" parts, 2 vinyl
figures; 2 screws; 2 vinyl tracks) |
| Pros |
Perfect "first model kit" for a young child, solid enough for "play
value" as well as detailed enough for many collectors; also available as a "built-up" version |
| Cons |
Not a true "kit"; where was stuff like this when we were little? |
| Skill Level |
Novice |
| MSRP (USD) |
$14.95, only sold via Wal-Mart |
While many iconoclasts spend their time bashing this or that kit for missing
one or two details, or whining as a kit of their favorite subject
has a "horrible" 2 mm error in its length, one thing which should
be observed by all of us is this: where are the "starter" or "entry"
level kits today that we can start our children on?
Many of us - no ages mentioned - began in the 1950s with a wealth of then-new
kits that beckoned to us from store shelves, even down at the
neighborhood "Mom and Pop" grocery. Aurora kits for 49 cents to
a mighty one dollar of everything under the sun, Revell matching
them stride for stride, and Airfix coming out with - wait for
it - common scale kits! Anyone of us with a dollar from a favorite
aunt or several weeks allowance could pick up some of these styrene
beauties and slap them together in an afternoon (hey, who needed
paint?)
My first armor kit was an Aurora M46 Patton the year it came out. I never did
get the little caps on right so the wheels never worked, but hey,
it had four guys that came with it and it was a TANK, so who cared?
I can't recall how many Tootsietoy trucks it blew up before becoming
a victim in its own right.
But as kits got more expensive - and kit reviewers like me showed up to start
raining on the manufacturers' parade - kits got more and more
accurate but more and more complex. It's one thing to give a kid
a model with about 100 parts or less and a simple method of construction,
and another to give him a kit with 700 parts that 50% of adults
cannot correctly assemble. With that high a cost to hours spent
on the hobby or hours spent versus frustration level, it's easy
to see why kids are less and less interested in modeling as a
hobby.
I spotted these models in a Wal-Mart last year but did not manage to get one
before they sold out. This year I saw the same kits back again
and picked one up to see what it presents to the younger modeler.
I was quite surprised at what I found.
First off, this is essentially the same offering as 21st Century Toys (a Chinese
import company exclusively under contract with Wal-Mart) makes
as a completed model in a "window" box with the figures in their
"action" poses. All this "kit" does is provide in a semi-knocked
down form so that "dad and lad" can put it together, together.
Not a bad concept, that.
The model is not bad either. It represents a standard production early hull
M4 tank with early turret and the M34A1 gun mount, albeit fitted
with late-model ("upswept") return roller brackets, T48 rubber
chevron tracks, and applique armor on the hull and turret. That
beats the old Revell kit, that looked like a Sherman but had nothing
in common with any specific prototype.
No sponson liners are included, so it is at least as good as any of the Tamiya
modern M4 series kits.
The model measures 181mm long x 82.5 mm wide x 84mm to the top of the commander's
hatch, which makes it about 1/32 scale. That's better than the
old Tamiya 1/30-something kit.
What you get when you open the box are a bunch of bags of parts or assemblies.
The hull, turret and belly pan are shipped as nearly complete
but separately bagged. Each is painted (albeit in a hurry) and
complete as is, less a handful of small detail parts for the lower
hull. "Assembly" consists of snapping the six extra parts in place,
slipping on the tracks, snapping the hull sections together, and
then using the two screws to hold them together. My own example
had a stiff-fitting turret and an underscale (and off-axis) hollow
bore to the main gun.
Some license has been taken. The hull hatches are overside and rectangular,
mostly to ensure the crew figures will fit in them. Tools are
molded onto the hull and quite high in relief, but at least in
the right places.
The model has been painted in the European camouflage used by most of the 1st
Army Group tanks with black stripes over olive drab. The crew
figures come painted as well, and consist of a seated driver with
tanker's helmet and a standing commander figure with steel pot.
Both the figures and the "kit" stowed on the tank have been washed
in black so they are essentially partially weathered. The model
does come with 10 packs, 2 crates, 2 oil cans, 2 gas cans, 2 spare
wheels, 3 sections of track, and 3 helmets as extra "kit" stowed
on the tank. Markings consist of generic stars.
The tracks and wheels roll, the turret traverses and the gun elevates and depresses,
the hull and turret hatch both open, as do the ejection port door
and the engine air intake access hatch (the front one, not the
one over the engine itself).
Overall this is actually a pretty impressive model, given its limitations.
There are a lot more in this family; I am not sure how big it
gets, but I have seen the usual Tiger I and 88mm kits, plus others
such as a US halftrack, M24 Chaffee, Wirbelwind and Moebelwagen,
Sd.Kfz. 7 8 ton halftrack, and even an early model Pzkw. III.
If you want to get kids interested in armor and armor modeling,
this seems to be a painless way to go. (But you HAVE to go to
Wal-Mart, as they seem to have a "done deal" on distribution in
the US.)
HOME
WHAT'S NEW
REVIEWS
FAQS
AIRCRAFT
ARMOR
SPACE
NAVAL
HISTORY
CALENDAR
COLORS
TIPS
COMING SOON
ABOUT
|